Commercial Therapy Claim Denials: Appeals Guide
A commercial denial on an outpatient therapy claim runs on a different set of clocks than a Medicare denial. Under the federal ERISA claims rule, a group health plan must give the member at least 180 days to appeal (29 CFR 2560.503-1(h)(3)(i)), must decide a post-service claim within 30 days of receiving it (29 CFR 2560.503-1(f)(2)(iii)(B)), and must allow at least 4 months after the final internal denial to request external review (45 CFR 147.136(c)(2)(vi)).
On top of that federal floor sit state prompt-pay laws, which carry real interest: 15 percent per year in California (Cal. Health & Safety Code 1371), 18 percent in Ohio (Ohio Rev. Code 3901.389), and 12 percent in Florida (Fla. Stat. 627.6131(7)). Whether those state laws reach a given claim depends on one question: is the plan fully insured or self-funded?
This post covers commercial (non-Medicare) denials for outpatient PT, OT, and SLP. For Medicare denials, see Medicare PT claim denials. What follows describes what the statutes, regulations, and payer pages say; it is not legal advice. Current as of October 2026.
Which rules apply: self-funded ERISA plan, fully insured plan, or neither?
ERISA “shall supersede any and all State laws insofar as they may now or hereafter relate to any employee benefit plan” (29 U.S.C. 1144(a)). Two clauses in the same section carve the line that matters to a billing office:
- The savings clause. Nothing in ERISA exempts “any person from any law of any State which regulates insurance, banking, or securities” (29 U.S.C. 1144(b)(2)(A)). State insurance law therefore still reaches the insurer on a fully insured employer plan.
- The deemer clause. An employee benefit plan is not to be “deemed to be an insurance company or other insurer” for purposes of state insurance regulation (29 U.S.C. 1144(b)(2)(B)). A self-funded employer plan is not an insurer, so state insurance laws do not apply to it.
The structure of the statute produces three buckets:
| Plan type | State prompt-pay, external review, and provider-dispute laws | What governs the appeal |
|---|---|---|
| Fully insured employer plan | Apply to the insurer (savings clause) | State law plus the federal claims rule, which the ACA incorporates for group coverage (45 CFR 147.136(b)(2)) |
| Self-funded ERISA plan | Do not apply (deemer clause) | The ERISA claims rule and federal external review |
| Governmental or church plan | Outside ERISA | Plan documents and state law |
The third bucket exists because ERISA “shall not apply” to a governmental plan or to a church plan with no election under section 410(d) of the tax code (29 U.S.C. 1003(b)). State and local government employee plans and most church plans therefore take their appeal rules from the plan documents and state law.
The practical tell: ask the payer representative whether the group is self-funded (an “ASO” arrangement, where the carrier administers the plan but does not insure it) or fully insured. The member ID card and the benefits verification often show it. A state prompt-pay deadline that applies to one patient’s plan may not exist for the next patient’s plan, even with the same carrier name on the card.
What does an ERISA plan owe you on a denied therapy claim?
The denial notice has required contents. It must state the specific reason for the denial, reference the specific plan provisions relied on, describe any additional material needed to perfect the claim and why, and describe the review procedures and time limits, including the right to bring a civil action under ERISA section 502(a) (29 CFR 2560.503-1(g)(1)).
If the plan relied on an internal rule, guideline, protocol, or similar criterion, the notice must either give it or state that it was relied on and that a copy will be provided free of charge on request ((g)(1)(v)(A)). DOL’s FAQ says a general statement that a rule “may have been relied upon” is not sufficient (DOL EBSA FAQ C-16).
Four more entitlements matter in a therapy appeal:
- The claim file, free. On request, the claimant gets “reasonable access to, and copies of, all documents, records, and other information relevant to the claimant’s claim for benefits” at no charge ((h)(2)(iii)). A document is relevant if it was relied on in making the determination, was submitted, considered, or generated in the course of making it, or is a statement of policy or guidance about the denied benefit ((m)(8); DOL EBSA FAQ D-12).
- No deference. The review must “not afford deference to the initial adverse benefit determination” and must be conducted by a named fiduciary who is neither the person who made the first decision nor that person’s subordinate ((h)(3)(ii)).
- A qualified clinician on medical-judgment denials. Where a denial rests on medical judgment, including a determination that treatment is “not medically necessary or appropriate,” the fiduciary must consult a health care professional with appropriate training and experience in the field involved ((h)(3)(iii)).
- Named experts. The plan must identify medical or vocational experts whose advice it obtained in connection with the denial, “without regard to whether the advice was relied upon” ((h)(3)(iv)).
The ERISA and ACA timeline in one table
| Step | Clock | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Plan decides a post-service claim | 30 days from receipt; one 15-day extension with notice | 29 CFR 2560.503-1(f)(2)(iii)(B) |
| Member or authorized representative files the internal appeal | At least 180 days from the denial notice | (h)(3)(i) |
| Plan decides the appeal | 60 days, or 30 days per level if two mandatory levels | (i)(2)(iii) |
| External review request | At least 4 months after the final internal denial | 45 CFR 147.136(c)(2)(vi), (d)(2)(i) |
| IRO decision | 45 days; 72 hours if expedited | (c)(2)(xii), (c)(2)(xiii) |
Two details that are easy to get wrong. The initial decision window is 30 days plus one extension of up to 15 days, only for matters beyond the plan’s control and only if the plan gives notice before the 30 days end; the 60-day figure belongs to the appeal decision, not the first decision ((f)(2)(iii)(B)). And in a two-level internal process, the 180-day period applies to the first level, and the plan must give a reasonable opportunity for the second level without a set period (DOL EBSA FAQ D-5).
Who can file the appeal: the clinic or the member?
Many clinics assume the assignment of benefits on the intake form lets them appeal in the member’s name. The DOL says otherwise. FAQ B-2: “An assignment of benefits by a claimant is generally limited to assignment of the claimant’s right to receive a benefit payment under the terms of the plan. Typically, assignments are not a grant of authority to act on a claimant’s behalf in pursuing and appealing a benefit determination under a plan” (DOL EBSA FAQ B-2). The same FAQ adds that the validity of a designation of an authorized representative “will depend on whether the designation has been made in accordance with the procedures established by the plan, if any.”
A plan may set reasonable procedures for deciding who is authorized to act for a claimant, and completing a form that names the representative is one such procedure (29 CFR 2560.503-1(b)(4); DOL EBSA FAQ B-1). For urgent care claims, the plan must let a health care professional with knowledge of the claimant’s condition act as representative ((b)(4)). Therapy appeals are almost always post-service, so that exception rarely helps.
The practical fix: put the member’s signed authorized-representative designation, on the plan’s own form or in a written designation that meets the plan’s procedure, into every appeal packet. Collect it when you decide to appeal, while the member is still reachable.
What is external review, and when can you use it?
After the final internal denial, a member in a covered plan can ask an independent review organization (IRO) to decide. The rules in 45 CFR 147.136 apply to non-grandfathered group health plans and to health insurance issuers; the section generally does not apply to grandfathered plans ((a)(1)(ii)).
- Window. The process must allow at least four months after receipt of the adverse determination or final internal adverse determination to file ((c)(2)(vi); the federal process says the same in (d)(2)(i)).
- Scope. Determinations that “involve medical judgment,” including those based on medical necessity, appropriateness, level of care, or effectiveness, are eligible ((d)(1)(i)(A)). Determinations about “the claimant’s failure to meet the requirements for eligibility” under the plan are excluded. A medical-necessity denial is external-review material; an eligibility denial is not.
- Timing. The IRO gives written notice within 45 days of receiving the request, and 72 hours for an expedited review ((c)(2)(xii), (c)(2)(xiii)).
- Binding. The decision binds the plan or issuer and the claimant, and the plan must provide benefits, including payment, “without delay” whether or not it intends to seek judicial review ((c)(2)(xi)).
- Deemed exhaustion. If the plan or issuer fails to strictly adhere to the internal-process requirements, “the claimant is deemed to have exhausted the internal claims and appeals process” and may go to external review or court. The de minimis exception does not cover a “pattern or practice” of violations ((b)(2)(ii)(F)).
State prompt-pay laws: deadlines and interest by state
The table below lists seven states checked against statute or regulation text as of October 2026. “Clean claim” definitions vary by statute; read the definition in the section linked in the last column before relying on a date.
| State | Clean-claim deadline | Interest or penalty | Statute (link) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Texas | 30 days (electronic) or 45 days (paper) for a clean claim from a preferred provider | Paid late but before the 46th day after the payment deadline: contracted rate plus 50 percent of the difference between billed charges and the contracted rate, capped at $100,000. Day 46 through day 90: 100 percent of that difference, capped at $200,000. Day 91 or later: the 100 percent penalty plus 18 percent annual interest | Tex. Ins. Code 1301.103, 1301.137; HMO: 843.338, 843.342 |
| California | 30 calendar days | 15 percent per annum from the first day after the 30-day period; plan must include accrued interest automatically or pay the greater of $15 or 10 percent of the accrued interest as a fee | Health & Safety Code 1371 (plans); Ins. Code 10123.13 (insurers) |
| New York | 30 days (electronic) or 45 days (other means); written denial or request for information within 30 calendar days | Greater of the tax-law corporate rate set by the commissioner or 12 percent per annum; interest under $2 need not be paid | Ins. Law 3224-a |
| Florida | 20 days (electronic) or 40 days (paper) to pay or notify of denial or contest | 12 percent simple interest per year on overdue payment | Fla. Stat. 627.6131; HMO: 641.3155 |
| New Jersey | 30 calendar days (electronic) or 40 calendar days (other) | 12 percent simple interest per year, from day 30 or 40 after the carrier has all required information | N.J.A.C. 11:22-1.5 |
| Ohio | 30 days, or 45 days if the payer determines supporting documentation is needed | 18 percent annual rate on claims not paid within the limits | R.C. 3901.381; R.C. 3901.389 |
| Virginia | 40 days from receipt, except where the obligation is not reasonably clear | Legal rate, computed daily from 15 working days after proof of loss (38.2-3407.1) | Va. Code 38.2-3407.15; 38.2-3407.1 |
These laws reach fully insured coverage, and not self-funded plans, because of the deemer clause (29 U.S.C. 1144(b)(2)(B)).
Not verified: Georgia and Illinois are omitted because their official statute sites block automated checks and no primary mirror passed our link check. Pennsylvania’s clean-claim deadline is 45 days (31 Pa. Code 154.18); the interest rate is set by Act 68, and this post does not state a number for it.
State external review and provider dispute rights on fully insured plans
Two examples show how state law can add to the federal floor on fully insured coverage.
New York. The insured has four months after notice of the final adverse determination to start an external appeal, and “where applicable” the provider has sixty days. The external appeal agent decides within thirty days of the request (up to five more business days if it asks for information), expedited appeals within 72 hours, and determinations are “binding on the plan and the insured” (N.Y. Ins. Law 4914).
California. Plans must keep “a fast, fair and cost-effective dispute resolution mechanism” for contracted and non-contracted providers. The plan may not set a deadline for receiving a provider dispute shorter than 365 days, must issue a written determination within 45 working days of receiving the dispute, and if the dispute is resolved wholly or partly for the provider must pay the amounts due “and all interest and penalties” within five working days (28 CCR 1300.71.38). This is a Department of Managed Health Care rule, so it applies to the health care service plans that department regulates; a self-funded ERISA plan is not one of them, for the deemer-clause reason above (29 U.S.C. 1144(b)(2)(B)).
Payer appeal paths: UnitedHealthcare, Aetna, Cigna, and BCBS of Texas
| Payer | Step 1 | Step 2 | Deadline | Where to send | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| UnitedHealthcare | Claim reconsideration request | Appeal, if you disagree with the reconsideration outcome | 12 months to complete both steps | UnitedHealthcare Provider Portal or an API; an upheld decision may appear as a letter in Document Library | UHC appeals |
| Aetna | Reconsideration (reimbursement, coding, reprocessing) | Appeal (written request to overturn, including medical necessity decisions); decision in 60 calendar days | Reconsideration within 180 calendar days of the claim decision; appeal within 60 calendar days of the reconsideration decision, or 180 calendar days for utilization review or claims appeals based on medical need or experimental/investigational criteria | Availity, or mail to the address on the denial; appeals by mail or fax to Aetna Provider Resolution Team, PO Box 14020, Lexington, KY 40512, fax 1-859-455-8650 | Aetna disputes and appeals |
| Cigna Healthcare | “Request for Health Care Provider Payment Review” form | Arbitration after the final internal level review decision, under the provider agreement | 180 calendar days from the initial payment or denial notice (from the last payment adjustment if Cigna adjusted the payment) | Mail to Cigna Healthcare Inc. National Appeals Unit (NAO), PO Box 188011, Chattanooga, TN 37422 (GWH-Cigna or “G” ID cards: PO Box 188062); coding-edit reconsiderations through the provider portal | Cigna how to submit |
| Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas | Claim Reconsideration Request; first review completed within 45 days | Second review, completed within 45 days of the second request | 180 days from the check date or Explanation of Payment date | Availity Essentials for finalized denials; by mail, the Claim Review form | BCBSTX claim review process |
UnitedHealthcare’s page says the process is subject to applicable law and refers timely-filing questions to the participation agreement, and Aetna’s says state-specific exceptions may apply, so treat the table as the default path as of October 2026 and confirm it against your participation agreement and your state. One payer-specific note from the pages:
- UnitedHealthcare gives no response-time commitment on its appeals page. A corrected claim must include “all lines from the original claim,” even those that were correct the first time. For UHC’s prior authorization program for commercial PT and OT, see UnitedHealthcare prior authorization for therapy.
Which denials to fight and which to write off
Appeal cost is staff time. The table sorts by whether the law and the record give you something to argue.
| Denial reason | What it usually is | Fight or write off | What to attach or do | Related guide |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Medical necessity | A medical-judgment denial: the payer says the service was not medically necessary or appropriate | Fight. This is the denial type the ERISA rule and external review are built for | Request the criterion relied on and the claim file; attach the evaluation, plan of care, latest progress report, treatment notes, and the payer’s own clinical policy with your criteria marked | Documentation requirements |
| Visit limit or unit cap exhausted | Either a hard benefit maximum in the plan document (a fixed number of visits per year) or a utilization-management cap (a vendor review that stopped authorizing visits, or a per-visit timed-code cap like the one in our visit-limits guide) | Hard maximum: a plan-terms denial, not a medical judgment, so not external-review material; whether it becomes patient responsibility depends on the contract, so check the contract and the benefit verification. Utilization-management cap: fight as medical necessity | Benefits verification and the payer’s policy document | Commercial visit limits |
| NCCI or modifier edit | A procedure-to-procedure bundling edit, a missing 59 or X modifier, or a missing therapy modifier | Usually a corrected claim, not an appeal. Fight only when the record documents a separate and distinct service | Corrected claim (UHC requires all lines); Cigna routes coding-edit reconsiderations through the portal | NCCI edits and modifier 59 |
| Timely filing | Claim received after the contract or statutory limit | Fight only with proof of timely receipt; otherwise write off, and check the contract on whether the patient can be billed | Clearinghouse acceptance report or payer acknowledgment. Statutory floors exist in some states: New York 120 days (Ins. Law 3224-a(g)), Florida 6 months (Fla. Stat. 627.6131(3)(b)) | Commercial visit limits |
| No prior authorization | An authorization was missing, or existed and was not matched to the claim | If an authorization existed, fight with the authorization number (Virginia requires payment of previously authorized services, subject to exceptions). If none existed, check the payer’s retro-authorization window; otherwise write off | Authorization number and date; retro-authorization request where the payer allows one | UnitedHealthcare prior authorization |
| Eligibility | Coverage terminated, wrong payer, or coordination of benefits | Not an appeal. External review excludes eligibility determinations | Re-verify coverage, bill the correct primary, and resubmit within the timely-filing window | Commercial visit limits |
What goes in the appeal letter
For a medical-necessity appeal, assemble the packet in this order:
- Claim identifiers and the denial reason, quoted. Patient, member ID, claim number, dates of service, codes, and the denial reason exactly as written on the remittance or letter.
- The request for the criterion and the claim file. Ask for the specific rule, guideline, or protocol relied on (29 CFR 2560.503-1(g)(1)(v)(A)) and for the claim file free of charge ((h)(2)(iii)).
- The clinical rebuttal, built from the record. The evaluation with objective measures and prognosis, the plan of care with measurable goals, the latest progress report showing change or the documented reason for a plateau, and treatment notes that show clinical decision-making. The five documents are covered in Medicare PT documentation requirements and the 10-visit progress report. Cloned notes read as unskilled care, as described in copy-forward and cloned documentation.
- The payer’s own clinical policy, with the criteria you meet marked. Mark each criterion and point to the page of the record that meets it.
- The member’s authorized-representative designation, on the plan’s form, if the clinic is filing for the member.
- The deadline you are filing under. State whether you are relying on the 180-day ERISA floor, the payer’s stated window, or a state dispute right, so the reviewer sees the appeal is timely.
Why is this live in 2026?
APTA adopted a position, “Unfair Payer Claim Denials” (HOD P07-26-07-04), at the 2026 House of Delegates, which met July 12 and 13; the motion, RC 01-26, was proposed by APTA Maine in the motion packet dated May 8, 2026 (motion packet), and APTA’s numbering note says the “07-26” in the position number refers to the July 2026 House minutes (APTA policy page; policy PDF). As of October 2026 the position opposes “arbitrary and capricious denials that force providers and/or patients to file appeals to get paid” and “payer policies that require the provider to justify the medical necessity of individual interventions for every occurrence when medical necessity justification has been previously provided in the plan of care or treatment records.” A companion position on unfair and deceptive practices by payers and intermediaries was adopted the same session as HOD P07-26-08-04 (APTA policy page). A position is not a law. On the legislative side, New Jersey A3257 is a pending bill, not law, that would bar a carrier from changing a network contract during its term in ways that reduce provider reimbursement (N.J. A3257).
Most of the work in a commercial denial is upstream: payer-specific billing rules that fire at the point of documentation, claims pre-scrubbed before submission, and rejections reviewed with suggested fixes. PrismEHR is built around that, with claim submission and tracking for Medicare and commercial payers. See how it fits physical therapy practices, and read how commercial visit limits trigger many of these denials.